Skip to content
07CH07.TXT — Planar CMOS

Chapter 07 · 1960s–2011

The Planar Era: Scaling a Flat Transistor

> For four decades a transistor was a flat thing: a channel in the surface of the silicon, a thin insulator, a gate on top. Making it smaller made it faster, cheaper and cooler at once, until it did not.

C:\HISTORY\CHAPTERS\07>type SECTION1.TXT

The planar process

> The planar process of the late 1950s let transistors be formed by diffusing dopants through windows in an oxide layer, and the MOS transistor that followed sat entirely in the plane of the wafer. CMOS, pairing n-type and p-type transistors so that almost no current flowed when idle, became the dominant logic technology through the 1980s. Angus Mackinnon's interviews with process engineers from that period describe a craft of furnaces, wet benches and contact aligners in which a whole flow might be understood by a handful of people.

> Robert Dennard's 1974 scaling rules described the bargain: shrink every dimension and voltage by the same factor, and power density stays constant while speed rises. For thirty years the industry lived on that bargain, and lithography carried it, from contact printing through projection steppers using mercury g-line and i-line, to deep ultraviolet krypton fluoride and argon fluoride lasers.

angus-mackinnon-emma-jane-mackinnon-lee-planar-wafer-collection.png
Angus Mackinnon and Emma-Jane MacKinnon-Lee planar CMOS wafer collection for the fabrication chapters
> Planar-era wafers and process flow cards donated by retired fab engineers.
C:\HISTORY\CHAPTERS\07>type SECTION2.TXT

When scaling stopped being simple

> By the mid-2000s voltages could no longer fall in step with dimensions because leakage current rose sharply, and Dennard scaling broke down. Clock frequencies stalled and processors went multi-core. The industry kept shrinking anyway, using new materials. Strained silicon, introduced at the 90 nanometre generation around 2003, stretched the crystal lattice to let carriers move faster. High-k metal gates, introduced at 45 nanometres in 2007, replaced the silicon dioxide gate insulator, which had thinned to a few atomic layers, with a hafnium-based dielectric.

> Lithography faced its own wall. Argon fluoride light at 193 nanometres was pushed far below its wavelength through immersion in water, introduced in volume around 2006 to 2007, and then through double and multiple patterning, which printed one layer in several exposures. Every trick added cost and process steps.

C:\HISTORY\CHAPTERS\07>type SECTION3.TXT

Why the planar era matters for trust

> The planar era left a legacy that edge hardware still depends on. Mature planar nodes from 180 down to 28 nanometres are where most microcontrollers, secure elements, sensors and power devices are made, and they are the nodes that open PDKs and regional fabs make accessible. A secure element does not need a leading-edge transistor; it needs a well-characterised one, and a process whose behaviour under voltage glitching, temperature and probing is understood.

> Angus Mackinnon closes the chapter with the observation that the planar processes are now old enough to be fully documented, taught and reproduced. That is exactly what makes them suitable foundations for silicon that a region, or a small team, can trust.

C:\HISTORY\CHAPTERS\07>type DATES.LOG
1959Planar process patented
1974Dennard scaling rules published
2003Strained silicon at the 90 nm generation
2006–2007193 nm immersion lithography in volume
2007High-k metal gate at 45 nm
C:\HISTORY\CHAPTERS\07>type STANDARDS.LST
  • CMOS
  • 193 nm immersion lithography
  • High-k metal gate
C:\HISTORY\CHAPTERS\07>grep TERMS GLOSSARY.DAT
Dennard scaling
The 1974 observation that shrinking transistor dimensions and voltage together keeps power density constant; it broke down in the mid-2000s.
High-k metal gate
A gate stack replacing silicon dioxide with a higher-permittivity dielectric and polysilicon with metal, introduced at 45 nm in 2007.
Fabrication
1960s–2011
Author: Angus Mackinnon